I. The Problem: Bankruptcy Based on an Outdated Balance Sheet
A company applies for concordat. The court first grants it a temporary moratorium and then a definitive moratorium. At the end of it, the board of commissioners submits its final report. According to the report, the company was over-indebted at fair market value in its balance sheet of a few months earlier. The local court therefore believes it should declare the company bankrupt directly. However, in its decision of 24 April 2025, the the Cassation Court found a balance sheet from a few months earlier insufficient for a bankruptcy decision.
In the lawsuit we examine, two companies and their shareholders applied for concordat together. According to the commissioners’ final report of 28 March 2024, one company was not over-indebted in its balance sheet of 31 January 2024. The other company, however, was over-indebted, with negative equity of about TRY 40.9 million. The local court approved the concordat projects. The Regional Court of Appeal then dismissed the appeals. The Cassation Court reversed the approval decision. For the company that was not over-indebted, it noted that the offer was not proportionate to the company’s resources. For the over-indebted company, it held that the court should “determine again, through an expert, whether the company is over-indebted at fair market value as of its current position” and should declare bankruptcy if the over-indebtedness continues. In this article we look at the criteria for over-indebtedness in concordat proceedings and at how up to date the balance sheet must be before the approval hearing.
II. Over-Indebtedness Criteria and the Balance Sheet Method
Under Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004 (“EBL”), Art. 179, a capital company’s over-indebtedness depends on an interim balance sheet that values the assets at their likely sale prices. When a concordat is rejected, the Cassation Court applies these provisions through the reference in EBL Art. 308/1. In short, the measure of over-indebtedness is fair market value, not book value.
Scholars also note that the board of commissioners or court-appointed accounting experts determine over-indebtedness through a fair value balance sheet. According to Bitlisli and Kıymık, a balance sheet prepared after the definitive moratorium gives more accurate results if it takes the debts at the amounts in the creditors’ claims and in the debtor’s acceptance. The 6th Civil Chamber also indicated that the conditions for approval concern public order and further accepts that, unlike the general rule in lawsuits, the court may also take into account developments after the application.
III. A Current Balance Sheet for the Bankruptcy Decision
Although it was not the main ground for reversal, the decision notably stresses the timing of the over-indebtedness review. During the definitive moratorium, the company collects its receivables, sells its stock and sees the value of its real estate change. For this reason, a balance sheet from the start of the moratorium may not show the position at the time of the decision.
The decisions have three consequences for the over-indebtedness review in concordat proceedings:
First, the measure of time is closeness to the date of the decision. One Regional Court of Appeal held that a fair value report prepared one and a half years earlier could not form the basis of the over-indebtedness review. Another decision found even balance sheets from three months before the decision insufficient. So even the balance sheets attached to the latest provisional tax return, which practice often relies on, may not be enough.
Second, it also matters who carries out the over-indebtedness review and how. In its decision of 9 September 2025, the Cassation Court reversed a bankruptcy decision given under EBL Art. 292/1-b. According to the Chamber, over-indebtedness at current fair market value concerns public order. A panel of expert witnesses should therefore examine it. The concordat commissioner’s final report alone may not be enough. The Chamber also stressed that, in a group of companies, the calculation should leave a guaranteed debt out of the guarantor company’s liabilities. Indeed, if every group company shows the same debt among its liabilities, the whole group may appear over-indebted on paper. We can say that the Cassation Court consistently expects an expert review in special situations like this.
Third, a request for an up-to-date review also depends on the debtor’s transparency and cooperation. In its decision of 15 September 2025, the Cassation Court upheld the bankruptcy of a company that withheld information and documents from the commissioner and whose recent turnover the commissioner could not check, despite the debtor’s objection that the balance sheet should use sale values.
IV. Conclusion: Bankruptcy Needs a Current Fair Value Balance Sheet
In a concordat, over-indebtedness should rest on a recent interim balance sheet at fair market value, not on an old financial statement. The earlier balance sheet keeps its value for assessing the project, that is, for the approval proceedings. A bankruptcy decision, however, cannot rest on it. For this reason, when bankruptcy becomes a possibility, it is quite critical for both the debtor and the creditors that a review close to the decision date updates the financial data. In special situations, the Cassation Court also increasingly expects an expert to carry out this review.
