I. The Problem: An Unchallenged Invoice and Proof of Delivery
A seller sends an electronic invoice to a buyer. The buyer does not object within eight days. The invoice also appears in the Turkish Revenue Administration’s system, in the buyer’s purchase report (“BA”) and in the seller’s sales report (“BS”). The seller now believes it can prove its claim. However, the 11th Civil Chamber of the Cassation Court rejected this view in its decision of 6 October 2025.
In that lawsuit, the claimant started execution proceedings for TRY 383,660.60 based on five e-invoices. The defendant objected and denied any debt. During the lawsuit process, the defendant admitted that it had missed the eight-day objection period by mistake. But it argued that it never received the goods and that the invoices did not appear in its commercial books. The invoices did, however, appear in the defendant’s BA record in the tax system.
This raises a simple question: If the buyer never objected to an e-invoice, and the invoice appears in the buyer’s BA record but not in the buyer’s books, has the seller proved delivery?
II. The Presumption for Unchallenged Invoices Does Not Cover Delivery
Under Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102, Art. 21/2, a person who receives an invoice and does not object to its content within eight days is deemed to accept that content. This presumption covers the ordinary content of the invoice, namely the type, quantity and price of the goods. According to Cankat and Güçlütürk, a seller does not need to deliver the goods before it sends an invoice. For this reason, the lack of an objection does not, on its own, show that the seller delivered the goods or performed the work. The Cassation Court has held the same view for years.
The seller still carries the burden of proving delivery, even if the buyer never objected. For commercial books, Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100, Art. 222 provides that if the other party’s properly kept books contain no record at all on the matter, the seller cannot use its own books as evidence in its favour.
III. A BA Record Does Not Prove Delivery
The most notable part of the decision is how it treats Forms BA and BS, which Türkiye abolished in September 2024. Through these forms, taxpayers reported their purchases and sales above a set amount to the tax authority, which used them to cross-check transactions.
Before the digital transition, one could read these reports as statements of intent. The BA filer said “I bought these goods or services”, and the BS filer said “I sold these goods or services”. The digital transition changed both how the forms worked and what they meant in law.
In the concrete case, the invoices appeared in the claimant’s books but not in the defendant’s. There was no delivery note or other proof of delivery. The invoices did appear in the defendant’s BA forms. But they appeared there because the Revenue Administration’s system imported the e-invoices automatically, not because the defendant reported them. For this reason, the local court did not treat the BA record as an acceptance of delivery, and it dismissed the lawsuit. The Regional Court of Appeal also dismissed the appeal. The 11th Civil Chamber of the Cassation Court then upheld the decision unanimously. It found no error in the reliance on the court-appointed expert’s report, which found that the defendant had no control over its BA form entering the tax authority’s e-archive system.
The decision has three consequences for the law of evidence:
First, the court dismissed the lawsuit even though the defendant admitted that it had missed the objection period. An unchallenged invoice fixes the content of the invoice, but it does not prove delivery.
Second, the Cassation Court upheld the view that a BA record is a system output, not a statement of intent. What matters are the records that reflect the parties’ real intentions. About two months later, in a decision of 11 December 2025, the 11th Civil Chamber upheld a Regional Court of Appeal decision against a buyer who had recorded the invoices in its books. That court had found that an invoice recorded in the commercial books creates a presumption, in the claimant’s favour, that the goods were delivered or the services performed. Scholars take the same view and treat a record in the books as a presumption of delivery.
About two months later, in a decision of 11 December 2025, the 11th Civil Chamber upheld a Regional Court of Appeal decision against a buyer who had recorded the invoices in its books. That court had found that an invoice recorded in the commercial books creates a presumption, in the claimant’s favour, that the goods were delivered or the services performed.
IV. Conclusion: The Seller Needs Separate Proof of Delivery
An e-invoice does not prove delivery, even if the buyer never objected to it and it appears in the tax system. If the buyer has not recorded the invoice in its books, the seller must prove delivery with a separate document.
For this reason, it is quite critical that the person who receives the goods on the buyer’s behalf signs the delivery note or the invoice that doubles as a delivery note, at the time of delivery. In practice, this is one of the strongest pieces of evidence. With it, the seller can prove delivery even if the buyer never records the invoice. Indeed, the Cassation Court has upheld a decision that found delivery proven through delivery notes, which the buyer’s employee had signed and later confirmed as a witness, even though the buyer had not recorded those invoices in its books.
